Saturday, 18 April 2015

Could communism work for Jamaica?


Cuba has asked Obama to remove them from the state sponsor list of terrorism and as such, Obama has moved to grant that request. It is said that Cuba has been one of the many states that practice some form of communism government. As such, they were seen as violating of human right. At least most of the states that has some form of communist concept, the international community has placed sanctions on them in hope that they will ‘conform’ and change their ideals. Countries such as Venezuela, North Korea and Russia, the international community has placed sanctions on them. But I would like to examine some of these countries that have some form of communist concept and examine how those countries are doing in terms of growth and other critical areas.


In China, there was a mass demonstration by the people protesting against their government that they would like the right to select their leaders – insisting on having a democratic government. We are yet to see if any result had come from that protest but the people were quite frustrated for whatever reason. Let us face it, China has become a world power, having one of the fastest growing economy in the world, which means you have less poverty, good health care and education system. China is a first world country and they did not automatically become one, the leaders had a vision and they did it their way – communism. A political scientist from china made mention that there isn’t one way to run a country and that is true. While democracy works for some country, communism works for others, would it work for Jamaica?

One of the main aspect that I would like to focus on is the crime rate of some communist states. Cuba has one of the lowest crime rate in the western hemisphere. Singapore which is a guided democracy – having some form of communist concept, has one of the lowest crime rate in the world, along with China and Rwanda in Africa. If you also look at these countries corruption levels, it is also among the lowest in the world. It also goes without saying that some of these countries has one of the best economies in the world. Investors flood these countries, what of Jamaica? If we really look at other critical areas these countries are leading globally. I am not being envious, nor am I saying we ought to adapt every policy from others, I just simply want to see Jamaica being place on a path of growth and prosperity where the citizens feel safe. In recent times, crime in Jamaica has been shocking! Could communism curb the crime monster? While communism work for others, it doesn’t work for some, would it work for Jamaica?


Truth be told, we are a very indiscipline nation. We need to develop a level of discipline and I don’t believe democracy will achieve such. Japan is a democratic state and has one of the lowest crime rates in the world, but democracy in Japan is not democracy in Jamaica. The democracy that exists in Jamaica is one that is poor, and failing. I cannot say definitively if communism would work for Jamaica but clearly democracy isn’t working. Many will say that it is the incompetency of our politicians that is the problem and not democracy because you can have democracy with competent leaders. While that is true, the flipside to that is democracy is the reason those incompetent persons are leading. I strongly support communism but because it usually comes with some violation of human rights, I don’t think it is ideal. However, if it would make me feel safe, live in a discipline country that is growing, I think I could work with that.

The Singaporean model seems fine, it is called a guided democracy – really close to communism. The truth of the matter is, if we can have leaders who are competent, who understand growth strategy and advancement of the people then it can work. As much as how Rwandan president has been chastised for human rights violation, you have a low crime rate, a disciplined nation, a growing economy, less poverty and more jobs. But with our current system, communism wouldn’t work for Jamaica. Alternatively, what I suggest is having term limits on these politicians because there is no way you should have a politicians serving up to until they are 80 – rubbish!  Our political landscape needs to be change, our government system need revamping, the Westminster model has overstayed its welcome, we need something new, something fresh, but the status quo seems that it will never be challenged. In the final analysis the question still stands, would communism work for Jamaica?